As an example, in the U.S. Presidential Election of 2024, the voting pattern from American Muslim and Arab electorates shifted significantly. Both communities have traditionally been solid supporters of the Democratic Party, generally siding with party positions on civil rights and issues of social justice and national security. However, in 2024, most Muslim and Arab voters appeared to break away from Vice President Kamala Harris, the Democratic candidate, and President Joe Biden primarily based on the administration's actions regarding the Gaza conflict. A growing dissatisfaction on issues over the economy and immigration, coupled with this shift, saw the outcome of many votes going into third-party candidates and even into the pocket of President Donald Trump in swing states such as Michigan. It delves into the most pertinent issues that led to the unprecedented break from the Democratic Party and the role played by third-party candidates as it enters its new and changing landscape for Muslims and Arabs engaging with American politics.
The Historical Loyalty to the Democratic Party
Before going into the possible reasons behind the 2024 shift, one should consider the historic loyalty of Muslim and Arab Americans toward the Democratic Party. This dates back to the post-9/11 era when attacks and the following war on terror made many Muslim and Arab Americans look for asylum in a party that then looked more concerned with problems of rights and civic freedoms. The Democratic Party's emphasis on social justice issues along with its more inclusive stance towards immigration, healthcare, and economic inequality was deeply sympathetic to these communities.
Reasons for Past Support
For two decades, the Democratic Party was seen as the party of progress, particularly for minority groups. The party's priorities for civil rights, healthcare reform, and anti-Islamophobia policies made Muslims and Arabs feel a political belonging. Following the 9/11 attacks, these populations faced unprecedented levels of monitoring, discrimination, and hate crimes in the early 2000s. The Republican Party under President George W. Bush was viewed as a supporter of anti-Muslim prejudice, owing partly to the War on Terror and the Patriot Act. Most Muslims and Arabs found refuge in the Democratic Party because that party was seen to have more inclusive policies, or at least to contest much of the war-orchestrated rhetoric emanating from the Bush administration.
Significant Elections Where Muslim and Arab Americans Played Key Roles
The greatest impact that Muslims and Arabs have made in American politics is the 2008 and 2012 elections, where then Senator Barack Obama voted overwhelmingly among these constituencies. Obama's rhetoric toward inclusiveness and his stance on the war in Iraq resonated well with Muslim and Arab Americans, who were seriously worried about the war taking place in the Middle East. Muslim and Arab voters again played a critical role in helping Joe Biden win in 2020, this time, particularly in swing states such as Michigan and Pennsylvania. In Michigan, where there is a large Muslim population, this time his strength helps him flip the state into his pocket, sealing that narrow victory. However, the 2024 election would see a marked departure from this long-standing loyalty.
Reasons for the 2024 Shift
Several factors contributed to the dramatic shift in Muslim and Arab voting behavior in 2024. Chief among them was the Biden administration’s handling of the Gaza conflict, which alienated many in these communities. In addition to foreign policy, issues like inflation, economic instability, and concerns over immigration played a role in the decision to break with the Democratic Party.
Gaza Conflict as a Decisive Factor
The Gaza war was another thing that made matters worse. It seemed as if most Muslims and Arabs were betrayed due to the full support of the U.S. government towards Israel as the war continued. Biden continued military aid to Israel and failed to ask for a ceasefire as everyone condemned him. That became a rallying cry for many in the community, who followed the devastations in Gaza, which had killed thousands of Palestinian civilians and left many others displaced. Many Muslim and Arab Americans felt the Democratic Party had not been doing enough on the humanitarian crisis or the rights of Palestinians under Biden's leadership.
As if from nowhere, third-party candidates made some headway with these populations from this particular piece's author the case of the Green Party, whose candidate Jill Stein explicitly declared ending the U.S. military support for Israel as her main plank of policy-making. The party's explicit stand on the end of the Gaza war and taking a pro-Palestine stance made many Arab and Muslim voters feel not so abandoned by the Democrats.
Economic and Social Concerns
Beyond the Gaza issue, other domestic concerns also influenced the Muslim and Arab vote. Economic issues, as was the case for many voters in 2024, dominated the reasoning behind their decisions. Inflation, a cost of living that keeps rising, and an unstable economy were the top issues in the minds of most voters in Michigan, Pennsylvania, and Georgia. Most of these voters are found in large Muslim and Arab-populated areas. Many of them were frustrated with the economic policies of the Biden administration, which they thought did not address these concerns adequately.
Issues on immigration and education issues aside, economic concerns also served as a decisive factor behind the choices of the voters. Perceptions about the seeming inaction of the Biden administration to address the immigrant issues especially border security and deportation served to fuel disappointment in the Democratic Party.
The Role of Third-Party Candidates
The 2024 election saw a surge in third-party candidates, but more particularly the Green Party's Jill Stein, whose campaign was more or less on the same wavelength as Muslim and Arab community concerns. She presented a great alternative to those voters who did not find their interest in Biden or Trump.
The Rise of Jill Stein and the Green Party
Jill Stein’s campaign was built around the message of peace and justice, particularly about the Gaza conflict. Her strong condemnation of U.S. military aid to Israel and her call for an end to the war in Gaza resonated with a significant portion of the Muslim and Arab electorate. According to the exit poll conducted by the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), most of the Muslim voters voted for Stein with more than 50%. Many voted for her over Harris and Trump.
Stein's campaign also focused on issues of foreign intervention, climatic change, and inequality from the economic perspective to help out the progressive voters who felt cheated upon by the two major parties. Although she did not have much in her media presence and budgetary resources, Stein's no-to-war stance helped raise the issue of concerned minds of the people disappointed because of the inactivity shown by the Democratic and the Republican parties on many vital issues affecting their living lifestyles.
Impact of Other Third-Party Options
In addition to Stein, other third-party candidates like Cornel West of the People’s Party also garnered attention from disillusioned voters. West, who advocated for progressive policies on social justice, healthcare, and Palestine, attracted a smaller but significant portion of the Muslim and Arab vote. These third-party candidates were seen as viable alternatives to the two-party system, which many voters felt no longer served their interests.
Trump’s Gains in Muslim and Arab Communities
Indeed, while much of the focus in the 2024 election revolved around a loss in popularity for Kamala Harris, Donald Trump still broke in with Muslim and Arab American voters and did so, especially in Michigan. Arguably no politician in modern history has been as anti-Muslim as Donald Trump. However, Trump’s outreach to these communities, particularly in swing states, was strategic and effective.
Campaign Outreach and Promises
One of the key elements of Trump’s strategy was his promise to bring peace to the Middle East. His campaign emphasized his desire to end the ongoing conflict in Gaza and to withdraw U.S. support from foreign wars. This message resonated with many Muslim and Arab voters, especially those who were disillusioned with the Biden administration’s failure to push for a ceasefire in Gaza. Trump's outreach to Arab American communities, especially in Michigan, where the Muslim and Arab American population is highly concentrated, helped him win support in traditionally Democratic areas.
Trump's campaign also did outreach to local Muslim and Arab American leaders, in an effort many saw as a direct appeal to people who felt the Democrats were ignoring them. By coming to key cities like Dearborn and Hamtramck - home to a significant share of voters with Arab ancestry - Trump attempted to reassert his position in those communities by speaking about economic growth and foreign policy issues.
Areas of Significant Support
The most dramatic shift was in Dearborn, Michigan largest Arab American population in the United States. In 2020, Biden won Dearborn by a notable margin. But by 2024, Trump had made huge strides here as well. In Dearborn, Trump took 42%, an astonishing rise of 15 from the last election, in contrast, Harris could only muster 36 percent, posting a drastic decline from Biden's impressive 70% in 2020. It was a similar picture in nearby Hamtramck as the vote share for Trump shot up meteorically.
Discontent with Democratic Leadership
Despite Trump’s outreach, the primary factor behind the shift in voting behavior was the dissatisfaction with Kamala Harris’s campaign and the broader Democratic leadership. Many Muslim and Arab voters felt that Harris and the Biden administration had failed to engage meaningfully with their concerns, particularly regarding the Gaza conflict.
Criticisms of Harris’s Campaign
Harris’s campaign was seen as dismissive of Muslim and Arab American concerns. Despite efforts to project empathy for the plight of Palestinians, her failure to make a clear break with the Biden administration’s policies on Gaza left many feeling unheard. The lack of engagement from Harris’s campaign, particularly in key swing states like Michigan, was seen as a strategic misstep.
Voices from Within the Community
Muslim and Arab American community leaders, political officials, and activists speak with openness about the Democrat's lack of care for very very strong issues that affect this constituency. Many now believe the Democratic Party has become complacent thinking those Muslim and Arab American voters will vote for the reasons the party takes such a seemingly pro-Palestine/ Gaza or other issues at hand side.
Broader Implications for the Two-Party System
The 2024 election revealed deepening fractures in the two-party system, particularly among minority communities like Muslims and Arabs. The shifting voting patterns indicate a growing disillusionment with both major political parties and a desire for alternative political platforms.
Is the Two-Party Model Failing Minority Communities?
Many in the Muslim and Arab American community begin to question whether two-party politics is an adequate framework for achieving their objectives politically. A third-party election demonstrates a need for greater inclusion in the political setup about the causes that marginalized communities face in societies.
Potential Long-Term Consequences for Democrats
The Democratic Party’s loss of support from Muslim and Arab voters could have long-term consequences. As these communities continue to grow in numbers and influence, their political engagement will be crucial in shaping future elections. If the Democrats fail to regain their trust, they risk losing a significant portion of the electorate in key battleground states.
Lessons Learned and Moving Forward
The 2024 election is a wake-up call to the Democratic Party. To regain the trust of Muslim and Arab Americans, the party must address their concerns more meaningfully, particularly on issues related to foreign policy and economic justice. Democrats must also engage more directly with these communities, offering clear solutions to the issues they face.
Opportunities for Re-engagement
For Democrats, there is still an opportunity to re-engage with Muslim and Arab Americans. By taking a more progressive stance on foreign policy and addressing the concerns of these communities in a sincere and meaningful way, the Democrats could rebuild the trust that has been lost.
The Growing Role of Independent and Third-Party Movements
The rise of third-party candidates reflects a broader trend of dissatisfaction with the two-party system. Moving forward, independent and third-party movements may play a more significant role in shaping the political landscape, particularly among minority communities that feel marginalized by the major parties.
Conclusion
The 2024 U.S. Presidential Election was the first election when American Muslim and Arab communities' voting behavior had changed decisively. For decades, these communities were considered Democratic Party faithful. They now showed discontent with the way the Democratic Party handled certain issues and decided to support third-party candidates or even Trump. This election was growing in disinterest with a two-party system, because the political class, especially parties, would need to connect more meaningfully with minority communities. Parties would need to reach out and resonate more with voters like Muslims and Arabs in these elections while shaping American politics for many years ahead.
0 Comments